Conversion of the loft, and extensions and alterations to the existing dwellinghouse
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Conversion/Use
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 25 October 2016
by Debbie Moore BSc (HONS) MCD MRTPI PGDip
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 31st October 2016
Appeal Ref: APP/B1740/D/16/3156946
16 Eldon Avenue, Barton-On-Sea BH25 7LL
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs Selby against the decision of New Forest District
Council.
The application Ref 16/10728, dated 24 May 2016, was refused by notice dated
8 August 2016.
The development proposed is described as “conversion of the loft, and extensions and
alterations to the existing dwellinghouse”.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is the effect of the development on the character and
appearance of the area.
Reasons
3. The appeal relates to a detached bungalow. The proposed development would
create a larger dwelling, with a higher ridge height and accommodation in the
roofspace served by glazed dormer windows to the front and rear.
4. The bungalow is located on a pleasant residential road that is described in the
Council’s New Milton Local Distinctiveness: Supplementary Planning Document
(SPD) (adopted June 2010) as a distinctive residential area of hip roofed
bungalows, wide streets with verges and front gardens. The key defining
elements are “consistency of street rhythms, building lines, gaps between
buildings, eaves heights and roof forms in bungalow areas – predominantly
uninterrupted hipped simple roofs and building forms”.
5. The re-developed bungalow would be of a larger scale than others in the area
due to its greater width and ridge height. This would increase the prominence
of the dwelling and it would be conspicuous in the street scene. A particularly
outstanding feature would be the relatively large front dormer window which
would project forwards of the hipped roof and would include a substantial area
of glazing. The modern design of the dormer would stand out as an
uncharacteristic feature. Also, the extended roof would be covered with grey
slate with timber cladding which would be in contrast to the traditional use of
brick and render, typical of the area.
Appeal Decision APP/B1740/D/16/3156946
2
6. I appreciate that the estate has evolved over time and many properties have
been extended to the side or rear, and some have modest dormer windows.
Nonetheless, these extensions are, in the main, sympathetic to the established
character and appearance in terms of scale, design and materials. The
neighbouring property at No 18 has been altered and extended but the
resulting dwelling complements the street scene. Similarly, No 16 has a rear
extension but this is not prominent in the street scene. I also looked at No 2
Eldon Close during my site visit, which has a significant roof alteration.
Although this development is less sympathetic than others, the site is a corner
plot with the gable facing towards Eldon Avenue. Consequently the
development has a limited effect on the strong rhythm to the appearance of
the street scene.
7. I believe that planning permission was granted in February 2010 for roof
alterations and a dormer window to the appeal property. There is no evidence
that the permission can still be implemented and consequently, I give limited
weight to it as a fall-back position. Whilst that proposal appears to have been
determined against the same policies as are currently in place, I do not
consider that this justifies a further uncharacteristic scheme.
8. The appellant refers to the permitted development right and states that this
would allow a larger side extension than is proposed. As explained above, there
are several examples of side extensions along Eldon Avenue which are
appropriate in terms of their size, scale and materials. The appeal proposal
includes a significant alteration to the overall scale of the dwelling which, when
combined with the roof extension and choice of materials, would not
complement the character and appearance of the area.
9. I do not have the full appeal decision at Wavendon Avenue, part of which is
quoted by the appellant, so I am unable compare this scheme with that before
me. In any event, each application or appeal must be determined on the basis
on its own site specific characteristics.
10. I have considered the information provided in respect of an appeal at Heathy
Close. This differs from the appeal proposal in that the roof form to the front
elevation would be hipped and would be consistent with the street scene in that
regard. Further, the Inspector was not persuaded that the slightly higher ridge
height would be overly perceived within the street scene. In contrast, the
appeal proposed includes alterations to the width and height of the original
property, a large front dormer and the use of contemporary materials. The
overall effect would not only be perceived in the street scene but would also be
harmful.
11. I appreciate that the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)
states that decisions should not attempt to impose architectural styles or
particular tastes. It is, however, proper to seek to promote or reinforce local
distinctiveness. The local distinctiveness of the area is effectively described in
the Council’s SPD and the proposal would be out of character with the
established pattern of development.
12. I have taken into account the appellant’s desire to improve their home, but this
does not override the conflict with planning policy.
Appeal Decision APP/B1740/D/16/3156946
3
Conclusion
13. I conclude that the development would be visually intrusive and would be
detrimental to the established character and appearance of the area. Therefore
it would not meet the aims of Policy CS2 of the Core Strategy1, which seeks to
ensure new development contributes positively to local distinctiveness and
sense of place, being appropriate and sympathetic to its setting in terms of [in
particular] scale, height, appearance and materials. The development would
not meet the aims of the Framework insofar as it seeks to promote or reinforce
local distinctiveness. The appeal should therefore be dismissed.
Debbie Moore
Inspector
1 New Forest District Council Local Development Framework: Core Strategy (adopted October 2009)
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.