Erection of a detached garage with office over
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Policy Weight
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 22 September 2016
by D Cramond BSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 05 October 2016
Appeal Ref: APP/P5870/D/16/3156667
47 Little Woodcote Lane, Carshalton, Surrey, SM5 4BY
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr W Brown against the decision of the Council of the London
Borough of Sutton.
The application Ref C2016/73811/HHA, dated 22 February 2016, was refused by notice
dated 15 April 2016.
The development proposed is the erection of a detached garage with office over.
Decision
1. I dismiss the appeal
Main issues
2. I consider the main issues are:-
Whether the proposal constitutes an inappropriate form of development
within the Green Belt for the purposes of the National Planning Policy
Framework (the ‘Framework’) and development plan policy.
The effect of the development on the openness of the Green Belt.
The effect of the development on the character and appearance of the
locality.
If the development is inappropriate to the Green Belt for the purposes of
the Framework and development plan policy, whether the harm by reason
of that inappropriateness, and any other harm, is clearly outweighed by
other considerations so as to amount to the very special circumstances
required to exist to justify the development.
Reasons
3. The appeal property is a detached dwelling with a generous garden in an area
of open countryside which also accommodates a scatter of generally sizeable
detached homes. The proposal is as described above and would have a
footprint of some 8 x 6.5 metres for garaging and access stairs with a smaller
office above served by 3 rooflights and a box dormer across most of one side
of the otherwise pitched roof.
Whether the proposal is inappropriate development
4. The Framework states that inappropriate development is, by definition,
harmful to the Green Belt and should not be approved except in very special
Appeal Decision APP/P5870/D/16/3156667
2
circumstances. The extension of an existing building is not, however,
inappropriate provided that it does not result in disproportionate additions
over and above the size of the original building. There is no definition of
‘disproportionate additions’ in the Framework. The Framework does not
specifically address outbuildings but in this instance I would find it reasonable
to treat the scheme before me as an extension to the dwelling given its
proximity to the main home and the intended uses.
5. The national policy advice has to be read together with the relevant
development plan policy which in this case includes Policy DM15 of the
Council’s Site Development Policies DPD (2012) (SDP). This policy allows for
extensions of existing dwellings in the Green Belt provided that the openness
of the Green Belt is not affected and that the increase in the floor area is no
greater than 30% above the size of the original dwelling.
6. The Council Officer’s report explains how the appeal scheme, cumulatively
with other past works, would bring the increase in floor area to over the 30%
mark. I have no reason to dispute that finding and the Appellant does not
argue against the sum or provide alternative evidence.
7. The original property and plot are sizeable and include some screening.
Nevertheless in my opinion, the ‘30% limit’ would seem a reasonable one to
apply in this instance and I see no justification to deviate from established
development plan policy. Whether taken by floor area, internal volume or
external bulk, the appeal proposal with previous works would represent a
change of significant scale and addition to the original dwelling.
8. I am in no doubt that the proposal before me would represent
disproportionate additions to the original building and run contrary to the
prevailing policy control for development in the Green Belt.
9. On the first issue, I therefore conclude that this proposal would represent
inappropriate development for the purposes of the Framework and would
conflict with the pertinent LP Policy DM15; it would result in a disproportionate
addition over and above the size of the original building. I attach substantial
weight to the harm caused by this scheme representing inappropriate
development.
Effect on Openness
10. The Framework makes it clear that an essential characteristic of Green Belts is
their openness. Open can mean the absence of development irrespective of
the degree of visibility of the land in question from public vantage points;
development which would harm openness could be acceptable visually. In
other words, openness of the Green Belt has a spatial aspect as well as a
visual aspect and the absence of visual intrusion does not in itself mean that
there is no impact on the openness of the Green Belt as a result of
development.
11. In this case the proposal would involve the addition of considerable floorspace
and a very notable new volume and bulk of development. The change over
the existing situation would be appreciable and the scheme would make a
marked difference to openness within this area. In common with the
Framework, SPD Policy DM15, as noted above, seeks to protect openness. I
conclude that there would be conflict with a key objective of development plan
Appeal Decision APP/P5870/D/16/3156667
3
policy and the Framework and I attach substantial weight to this impact upon
openness of the Green Belt.
Effect on character and appearance of the locality
12. By reason of its overall bulk and the architectural dominance of the large box
dormer the proposed building would be ungainly in form and it would be sited
uncharacteristically close to plot edges and the frontage road. These factors
would lead to a structure which would be out of character with its surrounds
running contrary to the attributes found locally of spaciousness and prevalent
landscape. It would not always be hidden from view and in any event it would
not represent good quality design.
13. On this basis I conclude that there would be conflict with SPD Policies DM1
and DM3 which, taken together and amongst other matters, seek to ensure
that development represents suitably scaled good quality design generally and
would protect local distinctiveness and the character of an area. The proposal
would also run contrary to the parallel objectives within the Council’s Urban
Design Guide: Creating Locally Distinctive Places. I attach substantial weight
to this issue.
Other considerations
14. The Appellant underlines that the generally substantial boundary treatment
removes or reduces views from short and longer range views. It is explained
that the scheme would not remove any vegetation of note. The garden would
still be spacious and the case is made that the ridge height of the planned
structure would be markedly below the main property giving the clear sense
of subordination. The argument is put that given the attributes of the site and
the planned design there would not be visual intrusion, adverse impact upon
character or landscape harm. The Appellant rightly draws attention to the
fact that the citing of SDP Policy PMP9 on the Decision Notice was not relevant
as that policy relates to safeguarding and enhancing the open space network.
15. I would give each of the considerations put forward by the Appellant limited
weight.
Balance and conclusions
16. In accordance with the terms of the development plan policies previously
highlighted and paragraph 89 of the Framework, the proposed development
would represent an inappropriate form of development in the Green Belt. The
Framework requires that substantial weight must be attributed to harm by
way of inappropriateness to the Green Belt. Additionally, I have found above
that the proposal would be unacceptably harmful to the openness of the
Green Belt and this also carries substantial weight.
17. Whilst I have afforded weight in the planning balance to the other
considerations raised in support of the development these, either individually
or taken together, do not clearly outweigh the harm to the Green Belt and its
openness which I have identified. Therefore, very special circumstances do
not exist and permission should not be granted as the proposal is contrary to
guidance in the Framework.
18. The fact that the development would have adverse impact upon the character
and appearance of the locality is a matter that adds to my concerns over the
Appeal Decision APP/P5870/D/16/3156667
4
proposal. However, whatever my conclusions on this non-Green Belt harm it
would not have made any difference to my findings on the question of very
special circumstances.
Overall conclusion
19. My overall conclusion is that the proposal would not accord with the pertinent
policy elements of the Framework and the development plan. The appeal
should therefore fail.
D Cramond
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.