Outbuilding in rear garden to be used as ancillary use to main dwelling as gymnasium
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Trees & Landscape
Noise & Disturbance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 26 September 2016
by Peter D. Biggers BSc(Hons) MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 06 October 2016
Appeal Ref: APP/N0410/D/16/3154593
Shergill Cottage, One Pin Lane, Farnham Common, Bucks SL2 3QS
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr M Gill against the decision of South Bucks District Council.
The application Ref 16/00237/FUL dated 12 February 2016 was refused by notice dated
12 May 2016.
The development proposed is outbuilding in rear garden to be used as ancillary use to
main dwelling as gymnasium.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for the outbuilding in
rear garden to be used as ancillary use to main dwelling as gymnasium at Shergill
Cottage, One Pin Lane, Farnham Common, Bucks SL2 3QS in accordance with the
terms of the application, Ref 16/00237/FUL dated 12 February 2016 and subject to
the following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than three years from
the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with the
following approved plans: 16.511/P.01A; 16.511/P.02A; 16.511/P.03A.
3) The materials to be used in the construction of the external surfaces of the
outbuilding hereby permitted shall match those used in the main dwelling.
4) No development shall commence until details of landscape works for the rear
garden to Shergill Cottage have been submitted to and approved in writing by the
local planning authority. These details shall include:-
boundary treatment; planting details ; pedestrian access and circulation areas;
hard surfacing materials; and an implementation programme.
The landscaping works shall be carried out in accordance with the approved details
before any part of the development is brought into use in accordance with the
agreed implementation programme.
5) The development hereby permitted shall be used solely for purposes entirely
ancillary to the residential use of the dwelling known as Shergill Cottage, One Pin
Lane, Farnham Common.
Main issue
2. The main issue is the effect of the proposed development on the living conditions
of present and future occupants of neighbouring dwellings in terms of outlook and
light and the future occupants of Shergill Cottage in terms of the availability of
private amenity space.
Appeal Decisions APP/N0410/D/16/3154593
2
Reasons
3. Shergill Cottage is a large dwelling currently being constructed on the site of a
smaller house. It sits towards the front of the plot and the proposed outbuilding
would sit close to the rear southern boundary. Because of the positioning of
neighbouring dwellings the outbuilding would sit between Poynings to the west and
No 23 Holly Close to the east which are separated from the Shergill Cottage plot by
timber fencing. The southern boundary to Clairmont is well screened by a fence
and mature trees and shrubs.
4. The proposal has been revised since submission of the application and before the
Council’s decision, to reduce the width, depth and height of the proposed
outbuilding, increasing the separation to the side boundaries to about 3 metres.
5. In respect of the impact on living conditions for neighbours to east and west of the
site, No 23 Holly Close has a ground floor window to a main habitable room facing
towards the proposed outbuilding and an outside patio area of the garden between
the window and the boundary. The window would be about 12 metres from the
gable end of the outbuilding and the patio area approximately 8 to 9 metres at the
nearest point. The existing boundary fencing would screen the gable wall of the
proposed outbuilding almost to eaves height and the fact that the building would
be set off the boundary by 3 metres with the shallow roof hipped away from No 23
means that the impact of the building would not be overbearing on the outlook
from the living room window and patio area. Moreover, the patio area, although
located behind No 23 on the side closest to the proposed outbuilding, is part of a
substantial garden area and the outlook from it is not restricted to a westerly
direction. As a result of the positioning of the outbuilding there would be a minor
loss of sunlight but this would be limited to when the sun is low in the western sky
during winter months and not such as to adversely affect living conditions.
6. Although the outbuilding would be closer to the neighbouring dwelling on the west
side, Poynings, the windows serving the habitable rooms in Poynings do not face
towards the proposed outbuilding and because of the position of the dwelling
relative to the outbuilding there would be no impact on sunlight levels.
7. With regard to the relationship to Clairmont to the south the boundary screening
and separation distance between Clairmont and the outbuilding is such that there
would be no impact. There would be 2 windows in the south-facing elevation of the
outbuilding but these would be set at a high level and would not enable any
overlooking southwards towards Clairmont.
8. It has been put to me that the result of constructing the outbuilding would be to
overdevelop the site and reduce the available area of private amenity space to a
size that would be insufficient for the large dwelling it serves. I note that there is
no standard minimum provision set for private amenity space by the Council and,
although I acknowledge that the remaining green space would be limited, it would
still be sufficient to accommodate the normal outdoor requirements of a garden
namely sitting out, children’s play, clothes drying etc. Moreover I accept that the
outbuilding itself, in providing covered leisure space for the house, with a mainly
open, glazed elevation towards the house and the garden, would contribute private
amenity space for the dwelling. I am not therefore persuaded that the reduction in
the area of outdoor private amenity space would unduly impact on the living
conditions of the occupants of Shergill Cottage.
9. Third parties have referred to concern over noise and disturbance. However given
the intended leisure use ancillary to the dwelling house and the form of the
building I am satisfied that noise levels would be unlikely to be any different to the
Appeal Decisions APP/N0410/D/16/3154593
3
levels that could normally be expected to be experienced between gardens.
10. The Framework in its core planning principles at paragraph 17 seeks to secure a
good standard of amenity for all existing and future occupants of land and
buildings. Policy EP3 of the South Bucks District Local Plan (SBDLP) is consistent
with the Framework in seeking to ensure the scale and siting of development
amongst other things does not affect the amenities of any nearby properties.
Policy H13 of the SBDLP deals specifically with ancillary buildings within residential
curtilages and sets out a number of tests including that the outbuilding should not
adversely affect nearby properties. For the reasons above the living conditions of
occupants in both Shergill Cottage and neighbouring dwellings would not be
adversely affected and policies EP3 and H13 would not be conflicted.
Other Matters
11. Third parties have raised a number of other concerns regarding the proposal.
12. The fact that there is a condition removing permitted development rights for
outbuildings on the original permission for Shergill Cottage does not mean that
development cannot take place, merely that permission must be applied for before
an outbuilding can be erected.
13. As applied for I am satisfied that the proposal to use the building in a manner
ancillary to the main residential use of the dwelling is appropriate for the location
and a condition could be attached to ensure that this remained the case. In the
event that the building was to be used for other purposes this would need to be
subject to a separate application which would be considered on its merits after due
consultation at that time.
14. As the building is not proposed to be used as residential accommodation it would
not add to the off street parking needs of the dwelling. Equally for the same
reason the outbuilding would not give rise to any drainage issues.
Conditions and Conclusion
15. I have considered the conditions suggested by the Council against the advice in
the Planning Practice Guidance and for their clarity. A condition requiring
development to be carried out in accordance with the submitted plans is necessary
as this provides certainty that the development would be carried out in the form
proposed. Control is also required to ensure use of matching materials in order to
safeguard the character and appearance of the property and of the surroundings.
The submitted plans refer to landscaping between the outbuilding and the plot
boundary and, as this would constitute a variation over what was proposed for the
landscaping of the main dwelling, I will impose a landscaping condition in order to
control the nature of that boundary landscaping. The appellant has indicated his
agreement to the application of such a condition. Finally in order to ensure that the
use remains entirely ancillary to the residential use of the host dwelling and in
order to protect the living conditions of occupants of Shergill Cottage and
neighbouring dwellings I will attach a condition limiting the use of the outbuilding
to ancillary uses incidental to the enjoyment of the dwelling. The Council proposed
this condition subsequent to the submission of the appeal and the appellant has
been given the opportunity to comment on it and has raised no concerns.
16. For the reasons given above, the appeal should succeed and planning permission
be granted.
P. D. Biggers INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.