Less-abled accessible proposed single storey one bedroomed annex
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Character & Appearance
Heritage & Conservation
Parking Provision
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 22 September 2016
by G Powys Jones MSc FRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 29 September 2016
Appeal Ref: APP/D0840/D/16/3151889
Rosedor, Cliff Road, Mousehole, Penzance, Cornwall, TR19 6PX
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Brian Martin against the decision of Cornwall Council.
The application Ref PA15/09003, dated 25 September 2015, was refused by notice
dated 24 March 2016.
The development proposed is described as a less-abled accessible proposed single
storey one bedroomed annex.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary matters
2. The appeal proposal is comprised of an annex intended for occupation for those
with limited mobility. Although sited very close to the main dwelling, the annex
would be detached and physically independent. The representations indicate
that the annex would be occupied by the appellant and his wife, an elderly
couple, and the main house would be taken over by their son, with the
intention that he would arrange and provide care for his parents as they grow
older.
3. The appeal property is located within the Cornwall Area of Outstanding Natural
Beauty (AONB).
Main issues
4. The main issue is the effect of the proposed development on the character and
appearance of its surroundings.
Reasons
5. The appeal property, a detached dwelling, is set on steeply rising land between
Cliff Road and Cliff Lane to the rear. It is one of several similarly sited
detached dwellings of various designs along this part of Cliff Road, also referred
to locally as The Parade. All the houses display generously sized front gardens,
whilst their rear amenity areas are far more constrained. Extensive and
attractive views over the sea are obtained from the front of these houses.
6. The annex would be built at the rear of the property, and its design takes
account of the lie of the land. The appellant describes the extension as
subservient to the host property. This may be the case in floorspace terms,
but the submitted drawings, including the sections, indicate that because of
Appeal Decision APP/D0840/D/16/3151889
2
site levels the flat roof of the annex would be set just below the main dwelling’s
eaves. In terms of its elevation and bulk, the extension would be perceived as
substantial, particularly when viewed from the rear.
7. The extension’s western wall would adjoin Cliff Lane and would be perceived as
a significant and sizeable continuation of the structures along this boundary,
including an elevated car parking space. Whilst adjacent properties display
some development to the rear, none display the same intensity of development
as proposed by the appellant.
8. Viewed from the rear, the proposed annex to my mind would be perceived as a
rather amorphous overdevelopment of the rear amenity space, having a
cramped and congested appearance. Being built so close to the host property’s
rear elevation, and given the ground levels involved, it would tend to visually
overwhelm it and the resultant visual relationship would be perceived as
awkward and contrived.
9. From oblique views to the front, the development would not be noticeable.
However, the annex would protrude to the side of the dwelling, and would be
clearly visible in front-on views. It would intrude into one of the gaps currently
separating the detached dwellings, which assists in lending the area a sense of
spaciousness. Although some intrusion into these gaps has already taken
place, it appears to me that further physical intrusion, as proposed, would
detract from the spacious character of the surrounding area.
10. I conclude that the proposed development would harm the character and
appearance of its surroundings by reason of its overdeveloped and congested
form. Accordingly, a conflict arises with the provisions of saved policies GD-1 &
GD-2 of the Penwith Local Plan (LP) requiring development to be integrated
with its surroundings and be in keeping with the character of the district, and
to respect traditional patterns of development and building styles. These
policies are not inconsistent with the Framework’s advice on design and attract
substantial weight in the context of its paragraph 215.
Other matters
11. I have taken into consideration the views expressed by the Town Council and
local residents, and have already dealt with most of the planning related points
raised.
12. I share the appellant’s view, largely because the appeal property is sited within
the built-up confines of the settlement, that the proposal would have no
material effect on the natural beauty of the AONB. I should also clarify that it
is not the modernity of the design that I find objectionable, but its intensity and
consequent effect on local character.
13. I have considered the appellant’s personal circumstances and motivation for
this proposal, and have balanced these aspects against the harm that the
development would cause to the character and appearance of its surroundings.
14. The family’s personal circumstances, in my experience, are not unique and I
find that little or no evidence has been presented to demonstrate as to whether
other possible solutions to their future aspirations as to their familial
connections have been examined.
Appeal Decision APP/D0840/D/16/3151889
3
15. I fully understand that the appellant and his wife may be closely attached to
the property, having lived there for so long, but this does not in itself justify
the approval of a development causing local harm.
16. Accordingly, on balance, the appellant’s personal and family circumstances are
not so compelling as to outweigh the environmental harm that would be caused
by their proposal, if implemented.
17. No other matter raised is of such strength or significance as to outweigh the
considerations that led me to my conclusions.
G Powys Jones
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.