Conversion of existing detached garage / workshop to provide 1 bedroom annexe ancillary to main 2 bed dwelling
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Open Space
Conversion/Use
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 23 August 2016
by M C J Nunn BA BPL LLB LLM BCL MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 28th October 2016
Appeal Ref: APP/L3625/D/16/3151426
4 Mayfields, Brighton Road, Kingswood, Surrey, KT20 6QZ
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against
a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr A Filbin against the decision of Reigate and Banstead Borough
Council.
The application Ref: 16/00309/HHOLD, dated 8 February 2016, was refused by notice
dated 6 April 2016.
The development proposed is described as ‘conversion of existing detached garage /
workshop to provide 1 bedroom annexe ancillary to main 2 bed dwelling’.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues in this case are:
i. whether the proposal is inappropriate development in the Green Belt
for the purposes of the National Planning Policy Framework (‘the
Framework’) and development plan policy;
ii. the effect of the development on the openness of the Green Belt; and
iii. if the proposal is inappropriate development, whether the harm by
reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm, is clearly
outweighed by other considerations, so as to amount to the very
special circumstances necessary to justify the development.
Reasons
Whether inappropriate development
3. The appeal site, which falls within the Green Belt, comprises a terraced
residential cottage with a small rear garden, accessed via a drive from Brighton
Road. Falling partly within the rear garden is a brick building with a corrugated
pitched roof comprising garages / workshops. This building straddles the
boundary of the enclosed garden to No 4 and extends southwards into a
communal parking area for the cottages. There are a series of double doors
opening on to this area. This proposal involves converting the end section of
Appeal Decision APP/L3625/D/16/3151426
2
the building closest to the host dwelling in order to provide a living / dining /
kitchen area, with a bedroom and bathroom.
4. The Council’s first reason for refusal refers to the proposal’s self contained
nature, lack of integration with the main dwelling and independent access,
resulting in a form of development capable of conversion to a separate self
contained unit. On this basis, the Council concludes the scheme would be
inappropriate development. However, I do not find the Council’s reasoning in
this regard to be convincing. The application makes it quite clear that the
proposal is for ancillary accommodation and not a new independent dwelling.
There is no reason for me to doubt that the building would be occupied as
ancillary residential accommodation to the main dwelling.1 Therefore, I have
assessed the appeal accordingly.
5. Of particular relevance to this appeal is Part 9 of the Framework. Paragraph 89
says that the construction of new buildings in Green Belts is inappropriate,
except in certain circumstances. One of the listed exceptions is the extension
or alteration of a building provided that it does not result in disproportionate
additions over and above the size of the original building. The appellant argues
the scheme should be considered under this exception. However, even if the
re-use of the existing building for ancillary accommodation could be regarded
as falling within this exception, the development as a whole cannot. This is
because it involves an enlargement and enclosure of the rear garden area on to
land currently used for communal parking. This element of the development
would not fall within any of the categories identified within the Framework as
‘not inappropriate’. I therefore conclude on the first issue that the proposal
taken as a whole would constitute inappropriate development within the Green
Belt.
Effect on Green Belt openness
6. The Government attaches great importance to Green Belts. The Framework
states that the fundamental aim of Green Belt Policy is to prevent urban sprawl
by keeping land permanently open, and that the essential characteristics of
Green Belts are their openness and permanence. The conversion of a section
of the existing outbuilding, with the insertion of windows and doors, would
result in a more domesticated appearance. It is difficult to see how this, in
itself, would significantly affect the character or openness of the Green Belt.
However, the enlargement and enclosure of the garden area into the communal
car parking area, whilst having little visual impact in the wider surrounding
area, would nonetheless reduce the openness of this part of the Green Belt,
albeit to a limited degree. Therefore, I conclude on the second issue that the
proposal would diminish the openness of the Green Belt. This diminution in
openness, although limited, would nonetheless harm its character.
Other Considerations
7. I have found that the development as a whole would comprise inappropriate
development, which is by definition harmful. In addition to the harm by
inappropriateness, there is a harmful effect on the openness of the Green Belt,
although this would be limited. Consequently, it is necessary to consider
1A suitably worded condition ensuring the outbuilding’s use as ancillary to the main dwelling could be applied were
I minded to allow the appeal.
Appeal Decision APP/L3625/D/16/3151426
3
whether there are other considerations weighing in favour of allowing the
appeal. The appellant says that the proposal would provide much needed
additional accommodation to meet family needs; that it would make the home
a better place to live; and that it would improve the appearance of the
converted building. The appellant also notes that the Council has not raised
objections to the design of the converted building, and also mentions the
scheme would be energy efficient. All this may be so. However, these factors
do not weigh heavily in support of the scheme, nor do they offset the harm
caused by it. Reference is also made to the Framework’s aim to boost
significantly the supply of housing. This proposal, whilst providing ancillary
habitable accommodation, would not of itself increase the supply of dwellings.
Therefore, this factor cannot weigh heavily in support of the scheme.
8. The appellant has referred to other appeals, including at Upper Buncton House,
Steyning2 and at Dunsborough Farm Cottage, Ripley3. Both schemes were
allowed, and concerned ancillary forms of accommodation. However, the first
case was not within the Green Belt. In the second, the Inspector concluded the
use of the barn for ancillary accommodation not to be an inappropriate form of
development within the Green Belt. The case before me differs in that the
enlargement and enclosure of the garden area means that the development
must be considered inappropriate development. Given the differing
circumstances, I do not consider either of these examples provides justification
for this appeal.
9. The appellant states he owns the land proposed for the enlarged garden area,
and is entitled to enclose it. Other residents dispute this. Whatever the
position, it does not alter the planning merits: the enlargement of the garden
area means the scheme as a whole must be considered inappropriate
development, which is by definition harmful. It should only be allowed if the
harm by reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm, is clearly
outweighed by other considerations, so as to amount to the very special
circumstances necessary to justify the development.
Conclusion
10. I have carefully considered the various arguments made by the appellant in
support of the appeal, but conclude that together they do not clearly outweigh
the harm the scheme would cause through inappropriateness, or in terms of
Green Belt openness. Consequently, very special circumstances do not exist.
The scheme would conflict with the Framework and would be contrary to Policy
CS3 of the Core Strategy and Policy Co1 of the Local Plan. Together, these
policies preclude inappropriate development unless very special circumstances
clearly outweigh the potential harm to the Green Belt. The development
cannot therefore be justified and the appeal is dismissed.
Matthew C J Nunn
INSPECTOR
2 APP/Z3825/A/14/2219412
3 APP/Y3615/A/13/2192670
Expert Representation
Technical Appeal Representation
This Change of use requires a bespoke technical strategy to succeed.
Contact Planzo for a professional review and quotation.